A rebuttal is a part of a debate where a speaker responds directly to the arguments made by the opposing team .
The goal is to prove that the opponent's arguments are wrong, weak, or less important than your own.Purpose of a Rebuttal
-
Refute the other team's points.
-
Defend your team's arguments.
-
Show logical flaws or lack of evidence in the opponent's case.
-
Persuade the judges that your side is stronger and more reasonable.
How to Structure a Rebuttal
A simple and effective structure is the “Four-Step Method” :
| Step | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1️⃣ They said... | Summarize what the opponent argued. | “The opposition says that social media reduces productivity.” |
| 2️⃣ But... | State why that argument is wrong or weak. | “But they didn't provide any credible data to support this.” |
| 3️⃣ Our response... | Provide your counter-argument or evidence. | "In fact, studies from Harvard (2023) show that social media can enhance collaboration in online learning." |
| 4️⃣ Therefore... | Conclude why your side is still stronger. | “Therefore, their claims about productivity loss are unconvincing.” |
Tips for a Strong Rebuttal
-
Listen carefully to the other side's arguments.
-
Take notes during their speeches.
-
Use evidence or logic — don't just say “that's wrong.”
-
Stay calm and polite , even when you disagree.
-
Connect back to your team's main arguments.
Example of a Short Rebuttal
"The opposition argues that online learning is ineffective because students get distracted.
However, this is not entirely true — distraction occurs in both online and offline settings.
Research by Cambridge University (2022) shows that with proper time management, online learners can achieve equal or better results.
Therefore, their claim that online learning is ineffective is not supported by evidence."
Motion
This House believes that Indonesia should implement a two-term limit for members of the House of Representatives.
This House would allow public voting to recall underperforming regional leaders
This House supports the relocation of Indonesia's capital to Nusantara as a step toward equitable development.
This House regrets the growing influence of political dynasties in Indonesia.
This House believes that Indonesia should prioritize political education in schools to strengthen democracy.
